Paul McGill, known as Old Dog New Tricks on YouTube, has become a controversial figure among expat communities in the Philippines for several reasons—some rooted in his content style, others in allegations and interpersonal dynamics including:

• Accusations of “e-begging”:
  Critics allege that Paul and his collaborator Baby Mae emotionally manipulate viewers to solicit donations. Some former fans claim they felt misled or pressured into supporting the channel financially.

• Past profession and trust issues:
  Skeptics point to Paul’s background as a car salesman, suggesting he uses persuasive tactics that feel more like salesmanship than genuine storytelling.

• Association with other creators:
  He’s been criticized for collaborating with more respected vloggers like Bud Brown, with detractors claiming he’s trying to “borrow credibility” from others in the community.

• Community backlash:
  On forums like Expat.com and Reditt, users have expressed frustration over his portrayal of Dumaguete and Valencia, citing burnout, negativity, and a tendency to complain about local conditions like power outages and small-town gossip.

• Polarizing tone:
  While some appreciate his candid, humorous style, others find it cynical or self-serving. His videos often walk a fine line between honest critique and perceived exploitation of cultural differences.

Despite the criticism, Paul maintains a loyal audience who value his transparency, relatability, and willingness to discuss uncomfortable truths about expat life. His channel offers a counterpoint to overly romanticized portrayals of retiring abroad.

Warning:
Don’t listen to the bull shit that comes out of his mouth, he used to be a car salesman after all.
Also the Baby Mae channel both working together pulling people’s heart strings for donations. I know a few disgruntled donators now and soon I will livestream with one of em who will come forward.